Depending on the amount of storage space you have available, you may find that it’s better to store keepsakes separate from the jewelry you plan to wear regularly.
Keepsakes can go in a separate drawer or you could display the pieces in a keepsake box.
For jewelry that holds a special meaning but just isn’t your style, consider repurposing the pieces. Search for a local jeweler able to create new styles using your existing jewelry. This is also a great way to get more life out of items that are broken or missing pieces.